Hold onto your seats, because Black Phone 2 isn’t just a sequel—it’s a bold gamble that dares to ask: Can lightning strike twice? After the haunting success of The Black Phone (2021), fans were skeptical. The original felt like a perfectly wrapped gift—a self-contained horror masterpiece. So, why revisit it? Director Scott Derrickson decided to take the risk, and while the result isn’t flawless, it’s undeniably gripping. But here’s where it gets controversial: Does this sequel truly add depth, or does it stretch the story beyond its limits? Let’s dive in.
Set four years after the first film, Black Phone 2 reunites us with Finney and Gwen, siblings still haunted by their childhood abductions. Finney, now 17, yearns to move on, but Gwen, 15, is pulled back into the nightmare. She begins experiencing eerie visions of a Christian camp and whispers of The Grabber’s return. And this is the part most people miss: The Grabber, who was definitively killed in the original, is back—but with a supernatural twist. This shift from gritty realism to a slasher-inspired, supernatural tone is both refreshing and risky. It’s a creative leap, but does it pay off?
The film’s logic bends under the weight of this new direction, leading to moments of confusion. Yet, it gives Derrickson room to experiment visually and emotionally. And boy, does he deliver. The mise-en-scène is stunning, thanks in part to a $12 million budget increase. Gwen’s visions, shot with a disorienting “found footage” style, add a layer of unease that elevates the film. The cinematography, lighting, and clever use of Super 8 footage give it a vintage, almost nostalgic edge—a standout choice in a genre often reliant on modern flash.
What truly shines in Black Phone 2 is its suspense. The pacing is deliberate, each moment building tension like a tightrope walker teetering over an abyss. The snowstorm isolation amplifies the chill, mirroring the characters’ fear and loneliness. It’s a masterclass in atmosphere, one that keeps you on the edge of your seat.
Madeleine McGraw, who plays Gwen, steals the show. At just 16 during filming, her ability to balance fear, determination, and anger is nothing short of remarkable. She carries emotional and combative scenes with a maturity beyond her years. Here’s a thought-provoking question: Is Gwen’s character arc the true heart of this sequel, or does the supernatural plot overshadow her growth?
Another highlight is the introduction of Ernesto, Robin’s younger brother from the first film. Played by Miguel Mora, who also portrayed Robin, this casting choice feels seamless. It’s a subtle nod to continuity and a welcome addition of Mexican-American representation in horror. But here’s a counterpoint: While Ernesto’s inclusion is commendable, does it feel earned, or is it a token gesture?
The sound design deserves a standing ovation. The low hum of wind, muffled echoes in the chapel, and the jarring ring of the black phone create a soundscape that heightens every moment of tension. Even the silence feels charged, proving that jump scares aren’t the only way to keep audiences on edge.
Where Black Phone 2 stumbles is in its storytelling. The supernatural return of The Grabber feels forced, diluting the realism that made the original so compelling. Here’s a bold interpretation: Was this sequel an attempt to cash in on the first film’s success, or a genuine effort to expand the universe? The script leaves too many questions unanswered. Why does Gwen have these visions? What’s the true nature of her connection to The Grabber? A clearer explanation could have grounded the story.
Another issue is the lack of genuine stakes. Once it becomes clear the main characters are safe, the tension wanes. The film remains entertaining, but by the end, it feels like there’s little at risk. Here’s a question for you: Does a horror film need constant danger to succeed, or can atmosphere and performances carry it?
Despite its flaws, Black Phone 2 is an enjoyable sequel that fans will appreciate. It surpasses the original in visual execution and atmosphere, even if its story feels stretched. Leaving the theater, you might still wonder why this film exists. But, as with a late-night phone call that sends shivers down your spine, the experience itself might just be worth it. So, here’s the final question: Does Black Phone 2 justify its existence, or is it a missed opportunity? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments!
